casablanca transformers full movie download the sixth sense gladiator full movie download blade ii full movie download batman begins full movie download the big lebowski star wars: episode iii - revenge of the sith robin hood: prince of thieves harry potter and the order of the phoenix full movie download gandhi there will be blood full movie download full movie download hancock full movie download children of men full movie download monsters. inc. goodfellas carlito's way full movie download blow full movie download full metal jacket the godfather: part ii full movie download full movie download desperado the assassination of jesse james by the coward robert ford full movie download full movie download silent hill 3:10 to yuma full movie download once upon a time in the west full movie download leon wedding crashers full movie download the english patient shrek 2 full movie download dogma full movie download batman & robin full movie download love actually armageddon full movie download full movie download garden state full movie download when harry met sally... full movie download chinatown full movie download borat: cultural learnings of america for make benefit glorious nation of kazakhstan full movie download iron man munich full movie download artificial intelligence: ai full movie download jackie brown top gun full movie download dracula full movie download full movie download city of god the game full movie download fargo air force one full movie download grease deep impact full movie download the last samurai x-men full movie download bridget jones's diary full movie download little miss sunshine full movie download casino royale ghost busters full movie download braveheart mission: impossible full movie download full movie download training day full movie download erin brockovich traffic romeo + juliet full movie download raiders of the lost ark full movie download resident evil the mummy returns the simpsons movie full movie download scarface full movie download lost in translation full movie download the bourne supremacy full movie download avp: alien vs. predator full movie download spider-man die hard full movie download the school of rock full movie download 2001: a space odyssey full movie download paths of glory terminator 3: rise of the machines full movie download mission: impossible iii full movie download eternal sunshine of the spotless mind full movie download full movie download the notebook twister full movie download the bourne ultimatum american gangster the lord of the rings: the two towers the da vinci code full movie download analyze this a history of violence full movie download the lord of the rings: the fellowship of the ring full movie download collateral juno 28 days later... full movie download star wars: episode iv - a new hope full movie download american history x the matrix full movie download pirates of the caribbean: the curse of the black pearl full movie download bruce almighty full movie download toy story 2 full movie download gangs of new york mystic river equilibrium full movie download no country for old men sweeney todd: the demon barber of fleet street dog day afternoon full movie download hot fuzz full movie download van helsing full movie download full movie download napoleon dynamite airplane! saw full movie download blade runner full movie download live free or die hard full movie download this is spinal tap full movie download full movie download the life aquatic with steve zissou wall-e full movie download sideways full movie download full movie download the prestige 25th hour fight club full movie download cloverfield full movie download harry potter and the sorcerer's stone the ring mars attacks! full movie download forrest gump full movie download the machinist indiana jones and the last crusade full movie download full movie download men in black ii harry potter and the goblet of fire full movie download ratatouille full movie download harry potter and the prisoner of azkaban full movie download the bourne identity full movie download rain man full movie download saw ii die another day full movie download the dark knight full movie download gone with the wind almost famous full movie download unbreakable full movie download gattaca star wars: episode vi - return of the jedi full movie download full movie download the silence of the lambs big fish raging bull l.a. confidential full movie download scream full movie download cruel intentions chicago 300 spartans full movie download terminator 2: judgment day full movie download the aviator hero full movie download x2 full movie download the thing full movie download groundhog day to kill a mockingbird full movie download king kong reservoir dogs full movie download apocalypto the last king of scotland the wedding singer full movie download ocean's twelve full movie download full movie download titanic brazil full movie download snatch. full movie download minority report kill bill: vol. 1 jay and silent bob strike back full movie download donnie darko tropic thunder full movie download edward scissorhands full movie download hellboy ii: the golden army full movie download die hard: with a vengeance full movie download the devil's advocate wanted full movie download hook full movie download full movie download the lord of the rings: the return of the king the incredibles the pursuit of happyness full movie download red dragon e.t. the extra-terrestrial full movie download full movie download glory fantastic four full movie download full movie download harold & kumar go to white castle full movie download natural born killers blade full movie download back to the future part ii full movie download full movie download 21 grams the perfect storm full movie download master and commander: the far side of the world meet the parents full movie download full movie download apocalypse now full movie download ice age kung fu panda full movie download crank the ninth gate full movie download the godfather: part iii life of brian spider-man 3 full movie download shrek slumdog millionaire as good as it gets full movie download indiana jones and the temple of doom signs snakes on a plane full movie download dead poets society full movie download contact a few good men full movie download

Bud Collins: U.S. Open draw is flawed

Tennis commentator Bud Collins was on ESPN this morning thrashing the U.S. Open women’s draw. His beef: The Williams sisters should be the top two seeds in the tournament. As it stands, Serena is seeded No. 2 and Venus is seeded No. 3. Collins argues that the two best players in the world are clearly Serena and Venus, and they should be the top seeds whether Dinara Safina is the No. 1player in the world or not (she is). The U.S. Open followed the world rankings for the top 7 women’s players.

Is Bud right? Should the Williams sisters have been 1-2? They were the finalists at Wimbledon and Serena beat Safina in the Aussie Open finals. Safina has never won a Grand Slam title; Serena is the defending U.S. Open champion. Safina is the world No. 1 largely because she plays more tournaments (two more this year) than the Williamses.

I’ll tell you this much: I’d put my money on Serena or Venus before I put it on Safina.




Blog Widget by LinkWithin

13 Comments on “Bud Collins: U.S. Open draw is flawed”

  1. #1 kick
    on Aug 31st, 2009 at 4:28 pm

    Bud needs to quit bitching. Just because the U.S. Open won’t get their Serena/Venus primetime night final this year doesn’t mean that the draw is wrong.

    I would agree that Serena should be #1, but Safina should be ahead of Venus, she has won more tourneys and been in 2 versus 1 finals this year.

  2. #2 scammerk
    on Aug 31st, 2009 at 4:47 pm

    I think no one really expects Safina to win it all, but that isn’t the point. She gets her no. 1 ranking based on her steady play throughout the year . Serena’s game rises to the top in grand slam play while Safina’s mind crumbles against top players. An argument can certainly be made for Serena to be seeded no. 1 based on her major appearances over the last year.
    This is certainly not the case for Venus Williams though. If you look at their last 4 Grand Slam results Safina has 2 runner-ups and 2 semis. Venus has a second round, third round, a quarterfinal and a runner-up. Other than a us open semi in 2007 Venus hasn’t made it passed the quarters of a non-Wimbledon major since 2003. I am no Safina fan, but she has earned her ranking. If people don’t like the fact that she is ranked higher than the Williams sisters, maybe they should put their efforts in getting them to play a little more.

  3. #3 david
    on Aug 31st, 2009 at 5:50 pm

    It’s time for all these people to quit complaining that Serena and Venus should be numbers 1 and 2. If they want to be one and two they should play more tournaments.

  4. #4 Ron
    on Aug 31st, 2009 at 10:21 pm

    I agree that Serena should be seeded #1, but not Safina ahead of Venus. Doesn’t matter what seed Serena is. She won the Australian Open as the 81st ranked player in the world. Venus hasn’t been playing well…and tonight we saw she’s suffering from patella tendonitis. So yes….Serena and Venus have themselves to blame for not being seeded 1 and 2 but they are both still better than Safina :lol:

  5. #5 Cyd Zeigler jr.
    on Sep 1st, 2009 at 12:56 am

    Ron, that’s exactly what I’ve been saying. Yes, they are probably better. But the rules are they rules, they know the rules, and they decide to not play in as many tournaments despite the rules.

  6. #6 kjmarker
    on Sep 1st, 2009 at 9:40 am

    The Williams sisters know how to get the # 1 & 2 seeds, play more tennis and finish higher than the others. Granted they have better overall slams records than Safina, but the seeds are based on World Rankings.

    Just imagine the complaints if it was the other way around, Dad Williams would have a field day if the girls seeds were reversed and not based on world rankings. All the players know that the top seeds are based on World Rankings.

  7. #7 JC
    on Sep 1st, 2009 at 12:52 pm

    In actual fact, Venus has a much poorer slam record over the past year than Safina.
    Safina has made the semis of all four majors and the finals of two. Venus made the finals of Wimbledon, but failed to make the semis at any of the other three. In fact, aside from Wimbledon, Venus has made only one major semifinal in the past six years. That doesn’t mean she can’t win here, but I don’t see much evidence that she’s the second best hardcourt player in the draw.

    Also, Venus and Serena have only played two fewer tournaments than Safina. But it doesn’t help to play more tournaments unless you win matches at them.

  8. #8 M Jonas
    on Sep 1st, 2009 at 12:57 pm

    Why this tennis groupie’s (Collins) views deserve any attention at all has always mystified me. He just tries to stir up controversy by taking adversarial positions. Pure showboating. Ignore him.

  9. #9 Jim
    on Sep 1st, 2009 at 1:08 pm

    The draw is flawed for an entirely different reason. As the No. 2 and 3 seeds, Serena and Venus should not be in the same half of the draw. Venus should be in the same half as Dinara Safina as they are seeded Nos. 1 and 3. It seems that the U.S. Open officials have deliberately placed Serena and Venus in the same half of the draw to assure that at least one of them will be eliminated (maybe by her sister) before the final so that we will not have another all-Williams Grand Slam final, which some fans are starting to find boring. This is likely motivated bya desire for stronger prime time television ratings for the final. Such concerns should not dictate how the draw is conducted. Serena and Venus do not beliong n the same half of the draw in this tournament.

  10. #10 George
    on Sep 1st, 2009 at 3:47 pm

    Jim with all due respect, that is ridiculous. First of all, the draw is NOT fixed. Years ago the number 2 & 3 seeds were always on the same side of the draw. A few years ago they changed it so that, like the rest of the draw, it would be random as to whether the 2 or 3 seed would be in the same half as the top seed. And while some fansmay find another Venus-Serena final boring (me included) it would still get much better ratings than a one of them against one of the ‘ovas or a final that doesn’t include either one of them. Belive me if the USTA was going to fix it, Venus and Serena would never ne in the same half of the draw.

  11. #11 Hako
    on Sep 2nd, 2009 at 3:02 pm

    I agree with M Jonas. Bud is a drama queen that loves to stir shit. Ignore him….I do.

  12. #12 Dave M
    on Sep 2nd, 2009 at 3:37 pm

    This same thing came up at Wimbledon before where non grass players were given lower rankings… Dinara should be #1 since she does well in everything else, but the grand slams. And even the Slams, she goes far. The Williams Sisters may excel at the slams but they just dont do enough outside. Mainly injury related! They compared Dinara’s record this year and it totally blows Serenas out of the water, mainly because she plays a lot more…

  13. #13 George
    on Sep 3rd, 2009 at 2:17 pm

    I haven’t researched it or anything but it seems to me like every year the US Open sticks more closely to the world ranking when seeding players compared to other Grand Slam events (surface maybe? I’m not sure.).

Leave a Comment