Sometimes when history is made it is so obviously overdue that it overshadows itself with larger questions. An article posted on Vancouver’s official Olympic Web site points out that history will be made today when French pairs skaters Yannick Bonheur and Vanessa James step on the ice to skate their short program.
The reason? Both Bonheur and James are black. It’s not clear from the article, which takes a celebratory tone, whether the author intended to underscore, or was oblivious to, the obvious: that the Winter Olympics are still the “white and Asian” Games.
“It’s often been remarked that we look different on the ice. So we want to highlight that,” said Bonheur. “We want to climb the ladder to show that black skaters can stand on the podium.”
As a supposed gathering of the world, the Olympics succeeds with sports like running, soccer, and basketball-all Summer Olympic sports-which are cheap and accessible to high percentages of the world’s population. By contrast, the Winter Olympics are composed entirely of niche sports in which a relatively few countries invest meaningfully in development programs for their athletes.
This, of course, is the inherent nature of the Winter Games, which have origins in wintry climates and require highly technical (and thus expensive) venues and equipment. But it is also why the Winter Olympics are less global, less competitive, and less-watched than their summer counterpart.
In 2010, Bonheur and James shouldn’t be this position. Figure skating should have marked today’s milestone decades ago, perhaps in Innsbruck in 1976 or Lake Placid in 1980. And the fact that it had not should remind us that Figure Skating’s flaws transcend the inherent homogeneousness of the Winter Olympics.
As recent as 2002, when a scandal erupted in Salt Lake City after a French judge voted for the Russian pair over the more deserving Canadians in a vote trading scheme designed to boost the chances of the French duo entered in the Ice Dancing competition. That’s just how business is done in the insular and corrupt sport of Figure Skating. And racial inequality is just another side effect of the sport’s institutionalized insularity.
The Winter Olympics must find a way to globalize itself if it wants to stay relevant into the future. Dozens of diverse and developed nations have ice rinks, which don’t require winter climates for training. The United States, France, Canada, Great Britain, and Australia should have invested earlier in programs that included black and Hispanic athletes.
In the meantime, I wish the best to Bonheur and James, and I hope the audience for tonight’s event isn’t as un-diverse as the field of competitors, so that the Olympic dream of young black kids doesn’t end when they don’t see anyone on the ice who looks like them. I just wish I didn’t have to write this post in 2010.
- By Ryan Quinn
6 responses so far ↓
1
DR
// Feb 14, 2010 at 1:45 pm
Ryan, you missed a skater, two actually. How can you write an article on minorities in the sport without mentioning:
Tai Babilonia,
Debi Thomas (1988 Olympic Bronze medalist and 1986 World Champ),
Surya Bonaly (5 time European champ, 3 time world silver medalist, and NINE time French national champion)
Rudy Gallindo (Nation Champ and World Bronze medalist)
Some may say “only three”, but they at least deserve a mention here.
2
Ryan Quinn
// Feb 14, 2010 at 1:53 pm
DR — I was writing about pairs skating, and both partners being black for the first time. But thank you for mentioning these names, if only to prove that there have only been three minority skaters in singles skating.
Surya Bonaly was one of my favorite skaters when I was growing up. She did a back flip once on the ice right in front of the judges (back flips were not allowed…) and I remember thinking: this girl is awesome!
3
DR
// Feb 14, 2010 at 4:01 pm
She did that in Nagano, IIRC, and it was her way of protesting her poor marks in the short program. She had guts.
And I didn’t want to detract from your point, just wanted to make sure that we recognize some well-known skaters. I know there have been a few more minorities, although none have made too big of an impact. I remember a young African-American male from many years ago in the US, and there was also an African-American female, Roberta something or other, who really has only ever skated pro. But yes, the numbers are small.
4
chandler20
// Feb 14, 2010 at 7:15 pm
I posted a link to the website “Black Ice,” which has a more complete listing of minority skaters.
There is a program started by Michael Weiss after he retired for skating scholarships…Kristine Musademba won one, and is a U.S. intermediate champion.
Elliot Halverson is a U.S. Junior National Champion who is Hispanic, born in Columbia.
5
sportinlife
// Feb 14, 2010 at 9:19 pm
Brave guy:
http://i.telegraph.co.uk/telegraph/multimedia/archive/01372/ice-skating-blue_1372779i.jpg
6
sportinlife
// Feb 14, 2010 at 9:20 pm
And gal.
Leave a Comment